The Athletic FC Podcast · March 16, 2026 · 36 min

Who is to blame for Liverpool's decline?

🎧 Listen to the full episode on The Athletic FC Podcast


Arsenal title race

Arsenal went nine points clear of Manchester City with an incredible cameo from a 16-year-old by the name of Max Dowman, who became the youngest goalscorer in Premier League history.

Ayo Akinwale

Liverpool's psychological decline

Once it got to October, November and it was like, 'Oh well, what are we trying to be now? We're like Man United or Aston Villa,' that's the group we're now in. I do think some of those really big players probably struggle a little bit with that from a motivation perspective.

Adam Crafton

Liverpool's internal management uncertainty

You've got three senior figures—Richard Hughes, Arne Slot, and Michael Edwards—whose contracts are all running out at the same time. If Liverpool are thinking about making a change about Slot, any manager or agent is going to want to know, 'Are these guys who are hiring me, are they sticking for the long term as well?'

Simon Hughes

Liverpool's defensive struggles

They conceded another late goal. I think it's the eighth late goal that they conceded this season. If you eliminated those goals, Liverpool would be just one point behind Man City.

Simon Hughes

Trent Alexander-Arnold's departure

Trent Alexander-Arnold was always going to be a bigger miss than people by the end of his time at Liverpool wanted it to be. He was an unbelievable player for Liverpool; he doesn't quite work at Real Madrid in the way that he worked at Liverpool.

Adam Crafton

Arne Slot's performance

Liverpool regardless of those imbalances on the squad should still be better than fifth or sixth this season. They should still be second or third based on what they've got available to them and they should still be going beyond the round of 16 in the Champions League.

Adam Crafton

Liverpool's tactical transition

You have an old style that is kind of on its last legs and a newer style that is kind of being phased in and I think the hope was you bring these two styles together and you get a fantastic team and a fantastic blend of experience and youth and it just hasn't worked out that way.

Adam Crafton

Liverpool's European form

Liverpool's record in Europe and knockout ties in the last six, seven, eight years at Anfield is actually not good. I think they've won one in seven or eight, which is surprising when you actually think about it.

Simon Hughes

Chelsea's performance

In terms of the amount of money that Chelsea have spent just to go slowly backwards is quite an achievement really.

Simon Hughes

Premier League Player of the Year

I think it's possible that Bruno Fernandes wins Player of the Year because I think there's a possibility that Rice sort of blows it out of the water. But I think there's also a chance that the vote is split between a few different Arsenal players.

Adam Crafton