The Athletic FC Podcast · March 17, 2026 · 34 min

Will Newcastle ever be an elite club?

🎧 Listen to the full episode on The Athletic FC Podcast


Newcastle United management

They entered the summer without a sporting director, without a chief executive, which is negligence, I would say, at the top of the club.

George Calkin

Manager/Board relations

Paul Mitchell came in as sporting director without his [Howe's] knowledge, without his input... He felt very unsupported in that moment.

George Calkin

Newcastle United progress

I don't think many if any Newcastle fans would say that their team is actually better than it was a year ago.

George Calkin

Newcastle United status

They'd proven that they were an elite team or that they showed that they could be an elite team, but they're not yet an elite club.

George Calkin

Newcastle United infrastructure

The first team raced ahead of the club in terms of progress. And the rest of the club needs to do Eddie Howe and the others a favour by showing that they're at his level.

George Calkin

Newcastle are still multiple years away [from a new training ground]. The stadium is even further into the distance again.

George Calkin

Newcastle United recruitment

It's about recruitment which has led to a lot of the issues this season. I don't think we're having this conversation if Newcastle have a striker who's on track for 20 goals a season.

Jacob Whitehead

Newcastle United transfers

Newcastle's selling has been disastrous... Anderson on his own would be worth 80, 90, 100 million and they have to get better at sellers.

George Calkin

It feels now as if that honeymoon's over for Voltemada... and when Visser eventually came back after a long-term injury he's just really struggled to hit.

Jacob Whitehead

Newcastle United finances

They're miles away from bringing in the kind of money as a club that they need to do to be able to compete with those more established names.

George Calkin

Tactical analysis

I think their first-choice midfield trio is amongst the best in Europe, Sandro Tonali, Joelinton, Bruno Guimaraes. They play with such intensity.

Jacob Whitehead